A New Kind Of Science? | Home: http://pwall.net |
Email: Needs JavaScript |
ON THIS PAGE:
OTHER PAGES:
|
For those of you who haven't seen it before, Life works like this.
Imagine a large (in theory, infinitely large) flat surface laid out in a
regular two-dimensional rectilinear grid. Each space on this surface is
called a cell and each cell has eight neighbours (including those that
touch only on the corners). A cell may be either alive or dead, and the
rules are as follows:
The rules were chosen by Conway after much experimentation because they
result in an interesting balance - some combinations of cells remain
stable, some enter repeating sequences, cycling through the same patterns
every two or more generations, and some create structures of amazing
complexity.
And a pattern of five cells known as the r-pentamino produces an explosion
of activity that doesn't quieten down until over 1000 generations have
passed. This is the pattern that was used in the example at the start of
this page, and among the generated patterns can be seen a number of
"gliders", groups of five cells which re-create themselves at a slight
offset, thus appearing to "walk" across the grid.
(The illustration at the top of this page is an "applet". For more about
applets see here.)
Life is an example of a class of conceptual frameworks called Cellular
Automata (CA). Life is a two-dimensional Cellular Automaton, but there
are also one-dimensional Cellular Automata and in theory a CA could have
any number of dimensions. Life has two states - alive and dead - but
there are examples of Cellular Automata with far larger numbers of states
and far more complex rules governing the transitions between those states.
Stephen Wolfram is a genius. That is not a word I use lightly, since I
have known a number of people with very high IQs, but I think in his case
the term is clearly justified. He received his Ph.D. in theoretical
physics at the age of 20, and later founded Wolfram Research, Inc. where
he produced the system Mathematica which is now one of the world's
leading systems for mathematical and scientific computing.
I don't know whether Wolfram read the same Scientific American articles
that I did, but at some stage he obviously became very interested in
Cellular Automata. But while I casually dabbled in the subject over a
period of years, Wolfram immersed himself in CA, devoting many years of
his life to very intensive research into the field.
The result of all this effort is a self-published book called A New
Kind Of Science. In it, Wolfram sets out his research into Cellular
Automata in great detail, and then goes on to draw some very controversial
conclusions from that research. To say that the book has had a mixed
reception would be a considerable understatement.
One reason for criticism is the name of the book. Many people have
questioned whether the word "New" in the title is justified, since Conway
and John von Neumann, among others, were working in this field decades
ago. Wolfram might claim that his inferences take Cellular Automata into
a whole new area - postulating that CA may underly the whole of
theoretical physics - but to say that this constitutes a new kind
of science is a bit of a stretch. A new application of existing science,
perhaps.
The academic community have also got their knickers in a twist over
Wolfram's chosen method of publication. They would have liked him to
submit a paper to one of the respected publications, such as the journal
Nature, which would then have kicked
off a standard process of peer review. Wolfram seems to have preferred
the review of the marketplace.
And something which seems to have got everyone's backs up, including mine,
is Wolfram's use of the first person singular throughout the book.
Perhaps a quotation from the very first page will illustrate:
Clearly, Wolfram is a man not over-burdened by modesty.
|
Links
The links in this column go to external sites and I am not responsible for
their content.
The presence of a link here does not constitute a recommendation or
endorsement of the site.
|